Voice America with Cynthia Brian

Wednesday, February 26th at 4:15 PST listen in!



Wrote a letter to the DA and I did get a response!

District Attorney office to S Geimer 03-11-2014

January 24, 2014

RE:  The State of California vs Roman Polanski & Roman Raymond Polanski vs The Superior Court of Los Angeles

District Attorney Lacey:

Allow me to introduce myself.  I am Samantha Geimer, the minor victim involved in the Roman Polanski sexual assault case. I write you to request that your office commence an official investigation into the alleged misconduct occurring in 1977 and 1978 during proceedings in The State of California vs Roman Polanski.  As the minor victim in this case any misconduct which may have occurred impacts me directly.  More importantly the fundamental fairness and justice in our criminal justice system is paramount above the individual concerns of the defendant and I or the State of California’s interest in prosecuting a case.

In Section VIII. Conclusion, of the Dec. 21, 2009, Opinion of the Second Appellate Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, it is stated that the Court remains deeply concerned that these allegations of misconduct have not been addressed.  Further, “Polanski’s allegations urgently require full exploration and then, if indicated, curative action for the abuses alleged here.  Time continues to pass, and the delay in addressing this matter has already removed one participant from the ranks of the available witnesses for an evidentiary hearing on the judicial and prosecutorial misdeeds that have been alleged here. The passage of more time before this case’s final resolution will further hamper the search for the truth and the delivery of any appropriate relief, and it will also prolong the agony that the lack of finality in this matter continues to cause Samantha Geimer.  We all exhort all participants in this extended drama to place the integrity of the criminal justice system above the desire to punish any one individual, whether for his offense or his flight.”

It has been four years since this opinion was issued.  Additional allegations that have been made and facts that have been revealed since the original proceedings have raised new questions and concerns about the treatment of this case in the years since 1977.  These include the recent statements and behavior of David Wells, recent revelations about Judge Fidler’s handing of the case (*please see link below) and Steven Cooley’s hostile attitude towards myself and the California Victims’ Bill of Rights.

I understand that your office has pressing and more current matters on which to commit its resources, but if not now, when?  The answer will be never, as eventually the original participants in the matter will not be available to testify.  I have been the lonely voice of a woman and a victim in a choir of the voices of powerful men and their individual agendas.  I ask only that you find the truth, that you demonstrate the integrity of the Los Angeles District Attorneys’ Office and seek that justice not be delayed or denied any further.

Thank you for your kind consideration.


Samantha Geimer

* http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/16/movies/emails-raising-questions-about-the-polanski-case.html?smid=tw-nytmovies&seid=auto&_r=2

cc: Attorney General Kamala D. Harris

Lawrence Silver

Lawrence Silver

My wonderful attorney as depicted by the court room artist back in 1977


So someone asked me to define “slut” for an interview on slut shaming

What is a slut?  I suppose if I had to define that word I would say it is someone who is sexually active with several partners or perhaps has sexual encounters of opportunity in addition to ones based on relationships. 

This word holds no power over me.  Perhaps it’s because of my experience of being called one as a rape victim at 13 years old.  Perhaps it’s because I grew up in the 70s, so I am pretty sure that I was one and do not hold that label in low esteem.  Back then the boys liked the girls that would fool around and treated us well, because, you know, they wanted to keep on fooling around.  I believe if someone calls you a slut in high school, they are either jealous that the boys they like are hanging out with you, or because you are hanging out with the other boys, not them.  But times have certainly changed.

I had hoped the horrible experience I had with the media and our community back in 1977 was a thing of the past.  But it seems that if you are a victim of sexual assault or just a woman or teenager who isn’t afraid of your sexuality, it’s a lot worse today.  Maybe it’s the different attitude towards sex.  I remember sex being thought of as a normal natural part of life you were meant to enjoy.  Today it seems sex is treated as a shameful and dirty act which leaves you damaged.  That’s a pretty unhealthy attitude.

The nature of this is sexist and based in conservative religious beliefs.    I have to wonder why any parent would want their sons and daughters to grow up with such damaging attitude towards sex.  I know we can’t go back to the days before AIDS and unbridled sexual freedom.   But human sexuality is a healthy and necessary part of life, making it ugly doesn’t make any sense.  So before you slut shame anyone, you should think about why you would want to hurt or judge anyone to begin with. 

And, if someone is slut shaming you, hold your head up high.  Own your own sexuality and don’t be ashamed of who you are or what may have happened to you.  You aren’t the one who has to go through life experiencing something that can be enjoyable and even beautiful, as something shameful and ugly.  Lucky you!


What now, in the real world

What now?  That is the question you ask yourself after you or someone you know has been sexually assaulted.  The terms sexual assault, molestation and rape include a range of abuses that begin with subtle coercion continuing through child molestation and encompass everything up to violent attacks.  The first thing to consider is what exactly happened regardless of the words you use to label it.  For a victim this can be a confusing thing to set straight in their own mind, let alone verbalize.  If someone is trying to share this experience with you, separate yourself from what has happened to them.  Do not put your own fears, outrage, anger or perception of how you would have experienced these events on the victim.

I put forward the thought that we should not force a standardized set of opinions on how a person is expected to feel or act when recovering from sexual abuse.  I believe we must allow them the freedom to choose their own feelings and actions, in their own time.

I was, of course, the victim in a very high profile sex scandal.  What has been added to my own experience is a lifetime of friends and acquaintances sharing their own experiences and those of friends and family members as well.  Perhaps they know I will not judge, perhaps since I refused to remain damaged and bitter they think I will have some helpful words.  I think that I have learned much about the different ways people process and recover from sexual abuse and how to support someone who is struggling.

First do away with your judgment, the initial reaction of “how could this have been prevented” is useless, it has already happened.  You may feel like if you just would have done something different, you could have avoided this.  Maybe it’s true, but the fault lies with the person who assaulted you, no matter what you did or didn’t do.  It is natural to feel some guilt or some shame, but that does not mean you are guilty or shameful.  These are feelings that you need to work through.  In supporting someone, understand this, do not deny or dismiss these doubts in a victim.  You can’t make them go away by saying these feeling are wrong, you have to understand that it is a common reaction, and validate that although the victim feels somehow responsible, what happened is not their fault.  You have to be allowed to express the feelings of guilt, shame or responsibility in order to work through them and not carry them with you into the future.

If the assault has just happened the first decision is who do your report it to, and will you report it?  If you have been violently attacked or the victim is a child, no matter how difficult, you should call the police.  Violent sexual predators and child molesters are likely to hurt someone else, if you don’t report it, they may continue abusing others.  Having said that, if you just can’t do it, then you can’t, you have to survive.  The moral obligation not to harm someone lies with the predator, not with you.  Victims do not cause rape, rapists do. 

When it comes to more subtle forms of sexual abuse, you may be even less likely to call the authorities.  You may feel that there is no evidence to prove what has happened to you, or prove that it was not consensual.  I think everyone understands that what you will go through in coming forward can be intimidating and may be a very bad experience, perhaps as in my case, worse than the event itself.

In 36 years I have learned many things and I am still learning.  It took me all this time and the recent revelations in the very public battle between Mia and Dylan Farrow vs. Woody Allen to finally “really” understand why my mother called the police when she found out what Roman had done to me.  As a sexually active teenager, I thought I was fine, after all it was just sex, I wasn’t injured and I was home safe and sound.   I had not been taught to have feelings of guilt and shame about sex, so I wondered how could the public shaming  we had to go through be worth it.  I was angry with her, but I eventually came to terms with it.  I’ve said I understood why she had to do it, but it was more of an intellectual understanding.  While I still like to believe I would have been fine if she didn’t, I now see what can happen when you don’t pursue charges.  However terrible it all was, I am now grateful that my mother refused to let Roman use me in such a disrespectful way and betray my family’s trust.  Her strength in standing up for me taught me a valuable lesson.  In the end I think what I went through made me a stronger person.  Consider that when you make your own choice, 20 years later will you still struggle to recover, feeling that you never go the justice you deserved?

The most important thing is for the victim to heal and recover under whatever circumstances exist.  If you choose to do this privately without involving the authorities, you will have to live with and accept that decision.  You can’t go back in time and change it any more than you can undo what happened to you.  So your fear at the moment, may override your ability to come forward.  You can make that choice, you are not obligated to anyone but yourself and your own recovery is the most important thing.  There are many reasons to encourage a victim to come forward, but if encouragement doesn’t change their mind, then you must respect their choice. 

When you do come forward you are likely to experience some of the judgment that I spoke of earlier.  What could you have done differently?  It is not fair but it seems that some have a very hard time not thinking that if you would have behaved differently, you could have avoided the assault.  It is hurtful, but you may be thinking some of these very things yourself.  You must know that whatever the circumstances, it is never okay to sexually assault someone and the responsibility lies entirely with the person who did it. 

My experience with these conflicting emotions, I think is shared by others.  I didn’t like being told I was responsible for nothing, it made me feel helpless and powerless.  In my own mind I could take responsibility for the bad choices I made, learn from them, and still put the blame entirely on the person who raped me.  I believe that you can live with that contradiction, you are not powerless.  You may wish you had made different choices, but the fault of what happened does not lie with you.

In the real world, not the world of high profile cases being tried in the court of public opinion, fueled by our “newsertainment” industry, things are handled differently.   A victim may tell no one, they may tell a family member or close friend immediately or years later, they may only tell part of the truth being ashamed to share it fully.   I think the most important thing to do when someone confides in you is to listen.  Refrain from judgment, don’t force your own emotions onto the victim.   Perhaps they are devastated, perhaps angry or ashamed, perhaps they feel that they will be okay and just want to share and talk it out.   However they feel it is valid.  My experience is that most people are kind and understanding, if you tell them what happened to you they will listen.  Often they will share that something similar has happened to them or to someone they know and tell you that they’re okay and you will be okay eventually too.  Behind closed doors survivors share and support, they include themselves in the collective and do not stay silent or isolated.  When things become public it’s more difficult.

As society we seem to need to force damage upon victims of sexual assault.  They are treated as if they are marked for life, injured, changed, unable to recover.  In part it seems that this is required to prove the perpetrators of these crimes have done a terrible thing.  The level of injury to a victim or their ability to recover from, it does not change the fact that sexual assault is a crime.  We should not demand that victims be unable to recover to prove that what happened to them is wrong.

Peoples’ feelings about sex play into this dynamic.  If you believe that sex is a dirty and shameful thing, you will project that onto victims of sexual assault.  If you have been taught that sexual activity is a sinful or ugly thing, you will project that onto yourself if you have been victimized. A healthy attitude towards sexual activity, knowing that sex is a normal natural part of a healthy life and not a shameful thing goes a long way towards recovery if you have been assaulted.  I believe it can help prevent sexual assault, if we teach our young people that sex is an ugly shameful thing, than what do we tell them rape is?  And as a society our need to place our own negative feelings about sexual activities on victims only pressures them further.

If you or someone you know has been assaulted remember this.  Whatever happened, whether you were dragged into a car and taken, assaulted by a stranger or an acquaintance on a walk home, if a family member, teacher or neighbor did something inappropriate with you when you were younger, or someone got you intoxicated and forced themselves on you, you can recover.  You are not damaged beyond repair.  However you choose to deal with it, it’s okay, it is your choice.  Whether you called the police or you chose not to.  Even if you didn’t and later wished you had, it is okay, you did the best you could.  If you never told anyone, if you repaired the relationship with family member privately, or if you told only a close friend what happened.  Whatever you did or not did not do, it was your choice.  You can heal, you can move on, you can find a place to fit this awful experience into your life and move on as a healthy person.  We can never undo what has happened.  Do not wait for circumstances beyond your control to change, so you can begin to heal.  If you still feel angry or afraid, that’s okay.  Forgive yourself, tomorrow is a new day, try again.  Just keep doing the best you can to find peace from within yourself that is the only place you will find it.

The proof is all around you.  My personal experience with survivors leads me to believe that the statistics estimating the incidence of sexual assault are much lower than the true figure.  I am here as proof.  My friends and family members are here as proof.  People you work with, strangers on the street, we are all here as proof to you that you can recover. Whatever happened, whether you received justice or not, whether you were believed or not, you can heal, you can recover, you can thrive.  There is no changing the past, there is only making a better future, for yourself, for those you care about, for those you will never meet.  Be proud that you have survived, support others who are recovering, you do not have to feel shame for being victimized.  The shame is for the person that assaulted you.

We all have our own unique experiences and paths, we do not have to accept being cast aside as a group of damaged objects. We can come together and use our success and our pride in surviving to shine a light into the darkness forced upon us by those who wish to close the door and look away.  The shame and stigma of sexual assault can be removed as easily as it was place upon us.  Refuse to carry the burden, refuse to place it on others, stand against those who try to make victims carry it with them.

Can anything positive come from the public Farrow vs. Allen fight

With all the accusations, heated debate, and ugliness incited by the tweets and articles in the Dylan Farrow vs. Woody Allen battle, I think the only question that really matters is: Can this help anyone else? We should operate on the premise that it must.

First, we should evaluate ourselves in the things we may have contributed with our tweets, blog posts, op eds, and casual conversations. If we said nothing that helps the broad range of victims of sexual molestation, we have done a disservice to them. Simply insulting this family or anyone who may disagree with you, does not count as making a positive difference.

I have been trying to find a glimmer of hope that this has all been worth something. The first person it should have helped is the victim at the center of it. I hope that her public statements in Vanity Fair and in the New York Times have brought her some comfort. Being able to speak your truth in the face of the very real fact that some will never believe you can be an empowering thing. Most victims do not have the benefit of major publications printing their words, nor the consequences of using such high profile platforms to be heard.  Let’s not forget those who are suffering right now, perhaps trapped in months or years of abuse with no escape, those who have no voice.

Dylan says in her open letter that she hopes she can help other victims come forward and heal.  On the face of it, my first reaction was that this painful public battle, in which there can be no winners only a very long list of losers, will not encourage anyone to speak out about their abuse.  Let’s not let that happen. 

We can instead address the real issues here, the facts we all must live with in order to have a civilized society. First, sexual abuse can be a very difficult thing for victims to admit and talk about. We should always err on the side of believing a victim because often these things can be very difficult to prove. Second, in America we are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This is not a trivial matter or a concept to disregard whenever we are all just “sure” someone is guilty. The fact that a guilty man may go free to protect the innocent from being persecuted is a value we as a society have given great importance.  We need to support and protect victims, but that imperative must coexist with our rule of law and the burden of proof. We see now that this can be a difficult balance.

We all have varied experiences and feelings. I did not want to prosecute Roman Polanski for raping me—it was very painful for me and I deeply resented my mother and everyone involved, feeling that they were doing me more harm than Roman had. My mother was not willing to let it go and demanded that at the very least he admit what he had done, regardless of what we may have had to endure. We suffered greatly to achieve that end. However we, like most victims, were not given a choice. Upon finding evidence that I may have been telling the truth, Roman was arrested and the District Attorney’s office set about prosecuting him to the fullest extent of the law. A plea bargain sparing me from testifying in open court was a very difficult outcome to achieve.

So what can we learn from these public battles? How can this help now? There is no undoing what happened 20 years ago, 35 years ago, or even one day ago. We can only try to prevent sexual assault in the future and help those who have already been victimized to recover. I think we can start with these ideas.


If you are a victim who comes forward and resolution through the court provides a conviction, it will not undo what happened to you. You will still have to heal. If you come forward and there is insufficient evidence for a conviction, that is a reality you will have to face, and you can find a way to begin recovering in spite of that. If you are given the choice not to prosecute and spare yourself the trauma of a trial, highly publicized or not, you can make your choice, go forward with your life and begin to heal. If you never come forward to the authorities, tell no one or only someone close to you, you can begin to recover and overcome what has happened to you. Under any of these circumstances, there will always be those who doubt you and nothing will erase what has happened to you. That does not have to stop you from healing.

The most important thing is to try to begin recovering from within. I don’t think you can heal from outside events happening.  Waiting for the actions of others— be it the courts, your family, the opinions of those you care about, or the words of strangers—places you in a situation that you cannot control. And despite what was done to you, you do still have control.

We place too many “musts” on victims.  You must come forward, you must display your damage, you must behave in a certain way, you must prove what you say is true. You must not be silent or you are responsible for the actions of a predator in the future. Only rapists cause rape, not the way you dress or behave, and certainly not how you choose to recover from being assaulted. It is time we allow ourselves “cans” instead of “musts.”  We can heal and recover under any circumstances. We can accept whatever has happened to us and however we have handled it. We can own our own truths and disregard the skepticism or disbelief of others. We can recover even if there is no punishment for the abuser.  We can come forward or we can heal privately. The only thing we can’t do is change what has already happened. 

Bitterness and retribution, regret and anger are things that poison you, they do not heal you. We are surrounded by people who may have suffered less or have suffered in ways we cannot imagine. Accept yourself, accept what has happened and how you have handled it. Give no one the authority to judge you and do not judge others in how they have chosen to recover. The last and perhaps most difficult thing, refrain from jumping to conclusions about the guilt of a person who is accused, but not charged with or convicted of a crime. I think we all have a lot of work to do.

The Girl – A Life in the Shadow of Roman Polanski

The Girl - A Life in the Shadow of Roman Polanski

Samantha Geimer, Lawrence Silver with Judith Newman